• Acerca de This Dawn
  • Contáctanos
  • Inicio 2
  • Política de privacidad
  • TD
This Dawn
Anuncio
Sin resultados
Ver todos los resultados
Sin resultados
Ver todos los resultados
This Dawn
Sin resultados
Ver todos los resultados
Innoson Vehicles Manufacturing Company, Nnewi
Inicio Opinión

For Nigeria’s Keyamo: Heavens May Not Fall, But the Sky Can Recede

Chidi Anselm Odinkalu por Chidi Anselm Odinkalu
November 15, 2026
en Opinión
241 13
0
Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN

Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN

508
VISTAS

Noticias de This DawnThere are two expressions that show how deeply courts, judges and politicians are intermingled in Nigeria today.

When politicians desire to signal how deeply their control of the courts runs, their dialect is mirth: “go to court!”

And to celebrate an improbable outcome snatched through undue propinquity to judicial robes, they gloat with “heavens will not fall!”

These are two sides of Nigeria’s alluring currency of impunity. Its remit runs everywhere — the executive, legislature, judiciary, bureaucracy, universities, contractocracy, faith organisations, and civic institutions.

Professor Chidi Odinkalu
The author, Professor Chidi Odinkalu

Even the uniformed services are not left out in the rat race for impunity. Those who have it want to maximise it; those who lack it seek its face.

In the past week, the debate on impunity in Nigeria has centred on the judgment on 5 November 2026 by Peter Lifu, a judge of the Federal High Court, nixing the slate of candidates of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) for the 2027 general elections.

Just call us for your Real Estate needs in Nigeria or UK. Just call us for your Real Estate needs in Nigeria or UK. Just call us for your Real Estate needs in Nigeria or UK.
ADVERTISEMENT

It is the most recent – but by no means the only one – of a slew of quite incredible judgments by a judge who has developed a genius for being the destination referee in the “endless family quarrels” of Nigeria’s politicians.

Much of this latest controversy has focused on the text of what Peter Lifu decided, but the trouble with this case precedes its outcome.

It is the evidence around it of what can happen when judicial administration is captured.

This case began on 2 September 2025 in the court of Emeka Nwite, another judge of the same Federal High Court.

The claimant was one Nafiu Bala Gombe, who sought judicial recognition as the rightful national chairman of the ADC.

To achieve this, he asked the court to de-recognise David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola in the roles of national chairman and secretary respectively of the party.

A procedural objection by the party travelled all the way to the Supreme Court, which decided on 30 April 2026 to return the case to Justice Emeka Nwite for hearing on its merits.

Four days after that decision, on 4 May 2026, Nafiu Bala Gombe delivered a letter to the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court, John Tsoho, inexplicably complaining that the case before Emeka Nwite had suffered “prolonged and inordinate delay” and asking the Chief Judge to transfer it to another judge.

Remarkably, the date on this letter was 4 April. That was nearly one month before the Supreme Court decided the appeal. That did not make logical sense.

Yet, the day after receiving Nafiu Bala’s transfer request, on 5 May 2026, Chief Judge Tsoho transmitted it to the lawyer for the ADC, Luka Musa Haruna, a Senior Advocate of Nigeria, SAN.

In a response dated 11 May and copied to the Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Haruna said Nafiu Bala’s request was “an odious effort” to impugn the integrity of the trial judge.

He instead, sought compliance with the order of the Supreme Court to return the case to  Emeka Nwite, and an accelerated hearing of the case.

Need solar power in your home? Just call us now! Need solar power in your home? Just call us now! Need solar power in your home? Just call us now!
ADVERTISEMENT

Three days earlier, on 8 May, upon being notified that Nafiu Bala had written to the Chief Judge to ask for the transfer of the case to another judge, Emeka Nwite adjourned the matter indefinitely to await the decision of the Chief Judge.

In the midst of this frenzy, on 14 May 2024, the National Judicial Council (NJC) recommended 12 judges to the president of Nigeria for elevation to the Court of Appeal. One of them was Emeka Nwite. Six months later, that recommendation still awaits the president’s attention and Emeka Nwite still works as a High Court judge.

Meanwhile, on 19 May, Chief Judge John Tsoho addressed a fresh letter to Haruna SAN in which he observed that the recommendation of Emeka Nwite for appointment to the Court of Appeal “constitutes an intervening event that makes the reassignment of this suit inevitable.”

The Chief Judge informed the lawyer that he had “therefore, reassigned this suit to Hon. Justice (Peter) O. Lifu for accelerated hearing.” He offered no reason why it had to be Peter Lifu.

At this time, Peter Lifu was already presiding over another case seeking the de-registration of the ADC. On 22 May, the Court of Appeal issued an order “staying further proceedings” in that case. That was a mere three days after the Chief Judge chose to send to the same judge yet another case seeking essentially the same outcome. He took no notice.

On 15 June, in defiance of the directive of the Court of Appeal, Peter Lifu issued judgment de-registering the ADC. Why then would he sit to decide the leadership of a party that he had ordered de-registered?

Two weeks earlier, on 1 June, in a four-page letter to Chief Judge John Tsoho, the National Secretary of the ADC, Rauf Aregbesola, protested the reassignment of the case saying, among other things: “we have serious concerns regarding the reassignment of politically sensitive matters involving opposition parties to a recurring group of judges of the Abuja Division, particularly, Hon. Justice Peter Lifu….” The letter named two other judges on this list. It also accused the Chief Judge of “administrative interference” with the proceedings and of undermining full compliance with the decision of the Supreme Court. The Chief Judge took little notice.

The ADC was not alone in noticing the pattern of assignment of political cases by the current Chief Judge of the Federal High Court. Law Akhigbe, who has analysed the pattern, publicly wonders “how so many politically explosive cases seem to find their way before the same judge”, positing that “when a judge repeatedly finds himself at the centre of politically consequential disputes, scrutiny inevitably follows.”

He is not alone. On 28 July 2026, the Court of Appeal overturned the decision of Peter Lifu to de-register the ADC, accusing him of the highest level of “judicial impertinence”, and calling him a “misfit on the bench.” The NJC, which has met since then, was unconcerned; nor, it appears, was Chief Judge, John Tsoho.

Peter Lifu’s latest judgment achieves the same end that the Court of Appeal overturned in its judgment of 28 July.

In response to this latest outing by Peter Lifu, Aviation Minister, Festus Keyamo SAN, joined the “heavens will not fall” gang, in capital letters. Babafemi Ojudu, a former Senator and presidential adviser, responded to him thoughtfully, inviting him to care about the country.

In a separate response, Olusegun Adeniyi argues that “when a minister of the Federal Republic, and a respected SAN, tells critics to keep quiet about a judgment with this history, he is not defending the judiciary.”

The political significance of judicial power is not in doubt. That is precisely why it needs to be conserved with care, not weaponized with recklessness. The price of failing to conserve it can be steep.

The index case, of course, was Nazi Germany. Ernst Fraenkel reminds us in The Dual State, his classic study of Adolf Hitler’s overthrow of democratic institutions leading to the catastrophe of the Third Reich, that “administrative and general courts aided in the achievement of this condition…., the purpose being the achievement of a political aim.”

When Kenya voted in a presidential election at the end of 2007, its judiciary was widely acknowledged to be “designed to serve the interest of the president and could not be trusted to pass impartial judgments, particularly where the president was involved.” So, the politicians sought to settle their electoral disputes in killing fields.

With the country staring down the edge of the precipice, those involved finally agreed to pull back. The price was a clear out of the judiciary. In 2010, the country began a re-set under a new Chief Justice whose record included political detention and exile. He had never sat previously as a judge.

Those –  like Festus Keyamo – living under the false assurance that the heavens will not fall stare in the wrong direction.

They should fear, instead, what may happen to the ground underneath them when some judges and their political patrons finally achieve the goal of rendering the courts irrelevant with a succession of noxious decisions.

The final moments as the earth satiates its anger and the skies recede in one terminal ‘woosh!’ could be worse than a collapse of the heavens.

A lawyer and a teacher, Odinkalu can be reached at chidi.odinkalu@tufts.edu.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
Previous Post

PHOTOS: Empty Stadium Greets Tinubu/APC at Jos

Next Post

Wrong, Magnus Onyibe; Roosevelt’s Subsidy Ended USA’s Great Depression (1)

Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

Next Post
Former American President, Franklin Delano Roosevelt

Wrong, Magnus Onyibe; Roosevelt’s Subsidy Ended USA’s Great Depression (1)

Stay Connected test

  • 396 Followers
  • 24k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Personal de la Policía nigeriana

EXCLUSIVE: Over 600 Police Officers Transferred from Edo to Kogi State Threaten to Abandon the Job Over Poor Welfare

21 de agosto de 2026
Ex candidato del Partido Laborista por North East Hampshire, Amran Hussain

Hussain: Reino Unido encarcela a político por título universitario forjado de Oxford

7 de agosto de 2026
Tribunal, Mazo, Justicia

Tribunal falla a favor de presidentes estatales en medio de crisis de ADC

1 de mayo de 2026
Presidente chino Xi Jinping contra el presidente estadounidense Donald Trump

Taiwán: China advierte a EE. UU. sobre venta de armas por 11.000 millones de dólares

19 de diciembre de 2025
Líder del Pueblo Indígena de Biafra (IPOB), Mazi Nnamdi Kanu

RADIOGRAFÍA: Cómo Nnamdi Kanu manipuló al IPOB

0
Presidente Donald Trump de los Estados Unidos contra el presidente Bola Ahmed Tinubu de Nigeria

Trump critica a Tinubu por visita al Reino Unido mientras Nigeria arde

0
Ex candidato presidencial del Partido Laborista, Peter Obi

Peter Obi reacciona al enfrentamiento entre Wike y un oficial naval

0
Activista de derechos humanos, Omoyele Sowore, contra el senador Ned Nwoko

Sowore desentierra el pasaporte de Regina, alega que Ned Nwoko se casó con ella siendo menor

0
Inspector-General of Police (IGP), Olatunji Rilwan Disu

EXCLUSIVE: Bout of Resignations Hit Nigeria Police

November 16, 2026
Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN

Who Is Festus Keyamo to Give NDC an Ultimatum?

November 16, 2026
Anambra State Governor, Chukwuma Soludo | President Bola Ahmed Tinubu

I Dare Soludo to Put Tinubu’s Picture on APGA Posters

November 16, 2026
2027 presidential candidate of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), Peter Obi, and his running mate, Rabiu Musa Kwankwaso, salute a cheering crowd

Obaze Alleges Plot to Disqualify Obi, NDC Candidates

November 16, 2026

Noticias recientes

Inspector-General of Police (IGP), Olatunji Rilwan Disu

EXCLUSIVE: Bout of Resignations Hit Nigeria Police

November 16, 2026
Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN

Who Is Festus Keyamo to Give NDC an Ultimatum?

November 16, 2026
Anambra State Governor, Chukwuma Soludo | President Bola Ahmed Tinubu

I Dare Soludo to Put Tinubu’s Picture on APGA Posters

November 16, 2026
2027 presidential candidate of the Nigeria Democratic Congress (NDC), Peter Obi, and his running mate, Rabiu Musa Kwankwaso, salute a cheering crowd

Obaze Alleges Plot to Disqualify Obi, NDC Candidates

November 16, 2026

Estamos preparados para brindarle lo mejor en noticias verificadas, confiables, fácticas y objetivas. Visite nuestra página de inicio.

Síguenos

Explorar por Categoría

  • Economía
  • Entretenimiento
  • Asuntos Legales
  • Noticias
  • Opinión
  • Política
  • Seguridad
  • Reportaje Especial
  • Deportes
  • Sin Categoría
  • Vídeos
  • Mundo

Noticias recientes

Inspector-General of Police (IGP), Olatunji Rilwan Disu

EXCLUSIVE: Bout of Resignations Hit Nigeria Police

November 16, 2026
Minister of Aviation and Aerospace Development, Festus Keyamo, SAN

Who Is Festus Keyamo to Give NDC an Ultimatum?

November 16, 2026

¡Bienvenido de nuevo!

Inicia sesión en tu cuenta a continuación

¿Has olvidado tu contraseña?

Recuperar tu contraseña

Por favor, introduce tu nombre de usuario o dirección de correo electrónico para restablecer tu contraseña.

Iniciar sesión

Añadir Nueva Lista de Reproducción

Sin resultados
Ver todos los resultados
  • Acerca de This Dawn
  • Contáctanos
  • Política de privacidad

This Dawn